Skip to main content

Prison economics. Part I.

The United States always tends to be the first one in any sphere. It didn't stay behind in the putting people behind the bars.The US has the highest incarceration rates in the world. The second place is taken by Russia. In 2007, the US peaked in its incarceration rates and those numbers are comparable with the imprisoned people during the years from 1934 to 1953 in Soviet Union ("The Gulag Archipelago" A. Solzhenitsyn). That is 23.4% of the world's prison and jail population was in the US, and this is while there is less than 5% of the world's population living in the US. Does it mean that people in the US tend to commit more crimes or is it a matter of profits to some?

Well, according to the professor in the University of Chicago, G. Becker (the founder of the theory of economics of crime and law enforcement, a Nobel laureate in economics): "The essence of the economic approach to crime is amazingly simple - It consists in the fact that people decide whether to commit a crime or not, comparing the benefits and costs of crime. Evaluation of benefits of committing a crime is pretty simple, those are mainly money benefits: stolen or criminally spent money, the value of stolen motor vehicles or items taken during burglaries and robberies, and so on." Economic approach suggests that people are rational in their decisions to commit a crime, thus, they weigh all the possible costs and benefits beforehand.  Let me not go far deep into the theory of committing a crime, but to the roots of such a huge number of imprisoned.

                                            Photo source: http://prison-visits.com/ 

Tel*Link - one of the biggest America's providers of phone services in prisons.While there is a monopoly to producer, prisoners face relative inelastic demand for phone calls to their lawyers or the loved ones. Research shows that increased communication with family while in prison reduces the risk that incarcerated people will re-offend after their release. But it seems that stakeholders do not want any competition there and thus keep the monopoly prices (up to $0.89 per minute). While the regulation is loose and certain reforms are being considered, prisoners continue making calls spending their last cent to bring an additional buck to a few people.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Basic principles of Tariff Classification

Tariff Classification is one of the main areas of Customs Law and is crucial when imposing customs duties. Specific rules on classification can be found in HS Convention to which almost all the WTO Members (except Taipei) are party. HS consists of over 5000 commodity groups with a six-digit code. HS consists of:  (1) Chapter, Heading and Sub-heading Notes; and  (2) General Rules for the Interpretation (GIR) of the Harmonized System.  The first one which is Chapter, Heading and Subheading Notes is the main step to identify the product classification.  The second part, GIR provide certain principles to classify goods:  (i) incomplete or unfinished goods if they don’t have a proper line are classified as finished goods; (ii) when goods are prima facie classifiable under two or more headings, classification shall be effected as follows. (a) A heading that provides a more specific description is to preferred to the more general description; (b) mixtures, c...

Mapping data - Kyrgyzstan Spatial

Recently Institute of Public Policy and Administration of University of Central Asia (IPPA-UCA) and International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) launched the online mapping tool named Kyrgyzstan Spatial (www.kyrgyzstanspatial.org). This application tool is a good way to see the socio-economic and food security situation in Kyrgyzstan. One may view the data on the map and see the regional differences in different sectors on national and sub-national level across time. 

Prison economics. Part II

Following my previous article on the issue of a huge incarceration rates in the US. Let me clarify that I am not trying to defend or justify the imprisoned. The only thing that interests me is the economics behind the crimes/prisons. Earlier in the year, President Obama signed the amnesty for illegal aliens that would forgive undocumented people and as a result award them with legal status (Green Card). This in turn will benefit 12 to 20 million undocumented persons currently being in the US. Looks like the authorities accounted that it is more beneficial as for the state budget in terms of extra taxes to be paid by the new legal aliens (up to 20 mln!), so for the illegal immigrants as well. In 1986 through Immigration and Reform Control Act (IRCA) was the first and only amnesty for a large group of people. Back then it was 2.8 million undocumented aliens. Just imagine the benefits to the state budget from this act. First of all there is no more need to pay $160 per imprisoned ...